Watson Consoles Blog

Feb 21, 2017 Health & Wellness, High Performance Environment, Before You Buy

The Dispatch Console Treadmill: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

Do I really want a dispatch console treadmill

As our collective pursuit of ever healthier work environments carries on, I wanted to take a moment and summarize Watson’s perspective and learnings on the controversial topic of treadmills at your dispatch console.  Since the early 90’s, we have designed our products to encourage healthy lifestyles and adopted many of the best practices as part of our core culture and it came as a surprise to many that we took a skeptical (and practical) stance on the dispatch console treadmill concept.

For those who are new to the topic of  treadmills at your dispatch console, head over to workwhilewalking.com and check out the FAQ on treadmill desks.

At first, the prospect of combining light exercise with work seems like a great idea. You can save time and achieve a level above the ubiquitous sit-to-stand desks all while crushing the Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion’s guidelines of 150 minutes or more of moderate exercise per week. That will lead to better health, more productivity and happiness, right?  The answer is yes… with a few caveats. The following is a summary of the key takeaways we’ve gleaned from our research and speaking with our customers and colleagues who have taken the step.

The Good

More movement means better health. 

This is a widely accepted and generally true principal. As previously mentioned, 150 or more minutes of exercise can lead to benefits including “lower risk of premature death, coronary heart disease, stroke, hypertension, type 2 diabetes, and depression.”  Additionally,  research has pointed out that compared to short, vigorous exercise, constant movement throughout the day is a far greater contributor to individual health.

 

Increased energy levels

I can personally vouch for the benefits of mid-workday exercise as a cure for afternoon slumps.  Whether taking a 2-3 mile walk or diving into a lunch session of cross-fit, I am able to return to work with a renewed focus and increased optimism to finish out the day.  The same principles hold true with more frequent exercise and continual walking on a treadmill while working.

 

Higher calorie burn

Among the chief benefits of standing, walking and moving more are the well-documented benefits correlated with increased calorie burn.  A 2011 study led by Timothy Church estimates that daily caloric burn is reduced by at least 100 calories when sitting.  There is no doubt that a treadmill at the desk will reverse this effect.

 

Reduced back pain

Many blog articles have been written that detail experiments with treadmill desks at work. A common theme is the reduction of back pain.  Likely a result of muscular tension balancing across the core muscles, there seems to be consensus that constant walking can reduce some instances of chronic back pain.

The Bad

The hassle factor

Regardless of how much you love your treadmill and your job, there are very few, if any, individuals that can actually walk on a treadmill for 16 miles a day.  Most people either need to be able to relocate to a second work area or replace the device with a chair as needed.  In practice, moving and storing the heavy equipment may prove more hassle than benefit.

They are expensive

Integrated treadmill desks retail for between $1300 and $2700!  Just for comparison, NordicTrack treadmills retail on Amazon for $700-$1300.  If the equipment is used every day, this may make sense, but many communications center adopters never realize the full return from such a large investment.

They are a novelty

A large majority of the customers we’ve interviewed since purchasing their treadmills have reported abandoning their treadmills after around 4 weeks.  At first the excitement and novelty drives a high rate of adoption that quickly fades when the marginal benefits cease to outweigh the hassle.

Limited capacity and durability

Potentially due to cost saving measures, or because some models are designed specifically for slow-pace walking, many office treadmills are not built to the same specifications as exercise grade equipment and don’t include the same warranty or weight capacities. 

The Ugly

Increased error rates

Working while walking on a treadmill is simply more difficult.  Although there are some accounts that claim improvement over time, typing accurately while walking is no easy feat.  

Personal hygiene

The bottom line is that if you’re moving fast enough to qualify your exercise as moderate, you’re likely also perspiring enough for your coworkers to take notice.

Noisy and distracting for othersA safe dispatch center promotes team focus. dispatch console treadmill

The noise of the actual machinery and the movement of your limbs can both be distracting for neighbors at work.  If purchasing a treadmill, pay close attention to the noise output and how your workstation will be positioned relative to coworker sightlines.

They can be a liability 

Last and certainly not least is the increased risk of injury and lawsuits.  The last thing you want as a manager is to lose valuable team members to injury at work if something goes wrong on the treadmill or as a reasult of its use.  In our opinion, you’re better safe than sorry.                

Dispatch Console Treadmill Alternatives

Fluid Stance is one non-treadmill option for health-minded dispatch centers. dispatch console treadmillAll in all, we support your decision either way and are happy to help you better understand how your choice of treadmill can be integrated into any dispatch console, including ours.  Alternatively, you might check out a few recommendations for other products that promote movement at your desk, without the hassle, risk and cost.

              Anti-fatigue mats

      Wurf Board

              Fluid Stance

    Underdesk Elliptical

 

If you'd still like to try a dispatch console treadmill, you can source them independently and integrate them with the workstation of your choice:

 


 

Was this helpful? SUBSCRIBE to receive more posts for high performance PSAPs.

 

Check out these posts for easy-to-integrate health habits.

 

Sources